Navy’s Friendly Fire Incident Raises Concerns Over Combat Readiness

The USS Gettysburg, a Ticonderoga-class guided missile cruiser, is under scrutiny after mistakenly shooting down a U.S. Navy F/A-18F Super Hornet in a friendly fire incident. The mishap, which occurred on Dec. 22 during operations in the Red Sea, has raised questions about the ship’s readiness and the Navy’s modernization efforts.

The Super Hornet, serving as a tanker for the Truman Carrier Strike Group, was on a descent toward the carrier when the Gettysburg launched an SM-2 missile. Mistaking the aircraft for a hostile target, the missile struck the jet, forcing the two aviators onboard to eject. Both were recovered alive, with one sustaining minor injuries.

Further issues arose when the Gettysburg launched a second missile shortly after the first. This missile narrowly missed another U.S. aircraft, exploding harmlessly over the water. The quick thinking of one aircrew and sheer luck prevented additional losses.

The Gettysburg’s history of modernization issues is at the center of the investigation. After being out of service since 2015, the ship underwent extensive upgrades, completing them in February 2023. However, a Government Accountability Office (GAO) report revealed significant quality concerns with the modernization program, including propulsion and electrical failures.

The GAO noted that the Gettysburg, one of only three Ticonderoga-class cruisers to complete modernization, faced over 15 years of delays and a 36% cost overrun. Despite undergoing successful missile tests in June 2024, doubts remained about the readiness of its combat systems and crew training.

Navy pilots have expressed frustration over the incident, citing insufficient training aboard the Gettysburg. Questions about whether the ship’s air defense systems were prepared for live combat have intensified, particularly given the ship’s critical role in protecting carrier strike groups.

This incident adds to a broader debate about the Navy’s ability to modernize and maintain its fleet. The Gettysburg’s performance highlights the need for further review of its systems and training protocols to prevent future friendly fire accidents.